Acupuncture Techniques: Needle Retention, Withdrawal, and Safety
Introduction
Acupuncture involves more than inserting a needle into an acupoint. Safe practice also requires appropriate needle manipulation, careful observation of the patient, correct withdrawal procedures, and the ability to recognize adverse events.
In my acupuncture techniques studies, I am learning that these steps are closely connected. Understanding the procedure itself is important, but understanding its potential risks and knowing when to seek emergency assistance are equally important.
This article reviews needle retention and withdrawal, common needling complications, and precautions that help support patient safety. It is intended for educational purposes and does not replace supervised clinical training, professional standards, or emergency medical care.
1. Needle Retention and Withdrawal
1.1 Needle Retention
Needle retention refers to leaving an acupuncture needle in place for a period after insertion and any initial manipulation.
In traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), needle retention may be used to continue stimulation or allow further manipulation during a treatment session. The appropriate duration depends on the treatment plan, the patient’s condition, the acupoint being used, and the practitioner’s training and clinical judgment.
For many routine acupuncture procedures, needles may be retained for approximately 10–20 minutes. However, this is not a universal rule. Some techniques require different time frames, and a needle should never be retained longer simply because a longer duration is assumed to produce a better result.
During retention, the practitioner should monitor the patient’s comfort and general condition. Further manipulation should only be performed when indicated by the technique and should remain within safe procedural limits.
In TCM terminology, deqi refers to the needling sensation traditionally associated with the arrival of qi. The sensation may be described as aching, heaviness, distension, or tingling. It should not be confused with severe pain, persistent electric-shock-like sensations, or symptoms suggesting tissue or nerve injury.
Key learning point: Needle retention is a clinical decision, not a fixed-duration rule. Patient safety and appropriate monitoring take priority over achieving a particular sensation or extending the treatment.
1.2 Needle Withdrawal
Needle withdrawal, also called needle removal, is the process of removing an acupuncture needle safely after manipulation or retention.
The general principles include:
Explain the procedure to the patient and ask them to remain still.
Remove the needle gently using the appropriate technique.
Avoid forceful pulling, twisting, or manipulation if resistance is encountered.
Inspect the puncture site for bleeding, swelling, or other unexpected changes.
Apply gentle pressure with sterile gauze when needed to control minor bleeding.
Dispose of used needles immediately in an approved sharps container.
Count the needles before and after treatment to confirm that all have been accounted for.
Observe the patient briefly after treatment and assess any symptoms before they resume normal activities.
Some traditional needling methods use specific withdrawal procedures intended to influence stimulation or the handling of the puncture site. These procedures should be learned through supervised practical training and applied only when appropriate.
If a needle becomes stuck, bent, or damaged, the practitioner should not attempt forceful removal. The situation requires careful assessment and, when necessary, appropriate medical assistance.
Keeping the puncture site clean and following infection-prevention procedures are essential parts of safe acupuncture practice.
2. Understanding Adverse Events in Acupuncture
An adverse event is an unwanted or unexpected occurrence associated with a procedure. In acupuncture, possible adverse events include fainting, difficulty removing a needle, needle bending or breakage, bleeding, hematoma formation, infection, and injury to internal structures.
Although acupuncture is generally considered a procedure with a relatively low risk of serious complications when performed appropriately, risks remain. Incorrect technique, inadequate anatomical knowledge, inappropriate needle depth or direction, unsuitable patient positioning, and failure to recognize warning signs may increase the risk of harm.
The practitioner’s responsibilities include prevention, early recognition, appropriate initial action, and timely referral for medical assessment.
The following sections summarize common complications from an educational perspective.
3. Needle Fainting
3.1 Definition
Needle fainting refers to fainting or a near-fainting reaction that occurs during or shortly after acupuncture. It may be associated with a vasovagal response, in which the nervous system temporarily affects heart rate and blood pressure.
3.2 Possible Contributing Factors
Factors that may increase the likelihood of a fainting reaction include:
Anxiety or fear of needles.
A first acupuncture experience.
Fatigue, inadequate food intake, or dehydration.
Physical weakness or acute illness.
Pain, emotional stress, or an uncomfortable position.
A previous history of fainting during medical procedures.
3.3 Signs and Symptoms
Possible warning signs include:
Dizziness or light-headedness.
Nausea.
Pale or clammy skin.
Sweating.
Weakness or a feeling of impending fainting.
Visual changes.
A slow or irregular-feeling heartbeat.
Loss of consciousness.
A patient who becomes unresponsive, has abnormal breathing, experiences chest pain, or does not recover promptly requires urgent medical assessment.
3.4 Immediate Response
If fainting is suspected, the practitioner should stop the procedure and remove the needles if this can be done safely and without delay. The patient should be protected from falling and placed in a safe lying position, provided there is no concern about a serious injury that would make movement unsafe.
The practitioner should assess responsiveness and breathing, monitor the patient’s condition, and follow the clinic’s emergency protocol.
If the patient is unconscious, breathing abnormally, injured, or not recovering promptly, emergency medical services should be contacted. If the patient is unresponsive and not breathing normally, cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) and an automated external defibrillator (AED) should be used according to the responder’s training.
Do not give food, drinks, or oral medication to a person who is unconscious or not fully alert. Do not rely on additional acupuncture or moxibustion as a substitute for emergency assessment.
3.5 Prevention
Prevention begins with a suitable patient assessment and clear communication.
Useful precautions include:
Ask about previous fainting episodes and relevant medical history.
Explain the procedure to help reduce anxiety.
Check whether the patient feels unwell, unusually weak, or significantly dehydrated.
Use a stable, comfortable position appropriate to the patient.
Avoid unnecessarily intense stimulation.
Observe the patient throughout treatment.
Respond promptly if dizziness, nausea, sweating, or other warning signs develop.
Key learning point: A fainting reaction should be recognized early. The first priority is patient safety and assessment, not completing the planned treatment.
4. Stuck Needle (Needle Entrapment)
4.1 Definition
A stuck needle, also called needle entrapment, occurs when an inserted acupuncture needle becomes difficult to rotate, lift, advance, or withdraw.
4.2 Possible Causes
Possible contributing factors include:
Muscle tension associated with anxiety or discomfort.
Excessive or inappropriate needle manipulation.
Repeated rotation in one direction, which may cause tissue to wind around the needle.
Sudden movement or a change in the patient’s position.
Local muscle spasm.
4.3 Signs and Symptoms
The practitioner may notice unusual resistance when attempting to manipulate or remove the needle. The patient may experience discomfort or pain.
Resistance should never be overcome by applying greater force.
4.4 Management Principles
The practitioner should stop forceful manipulation and ask the patient to remain still. The patient’s comfort and position should be reassessed.
Depending on the circumstances, a practitioner trained in the relevant technique may be able to release the resistance with gentle, controlled adjustments. If the cause is unclear, pain is significant, or the needle cannot be removed safely, appropriate clinical assistance should be obtained.
The needle should not be forcibly twisted, pulled, or pushed. Unnecessary additional needling should also be avoided.
4.5 Prevention
Preventive measures include:
Explaining the procedure to reduce anxiety.
Selecting a comfortable and stable patient position before insertion.
Using appropriate manipulation techniques.
Avoiding excessive rotation or force.
Asking the patient to remain still while needles are inserted, manipulated, and retained.
Key learning point: Resistance during needle manipulation is a reason to stop and reassess, not to apply more force.
5. Bent Needle
5.1 Definition
A bent needle is an acupuncture needle whose shaft becomes curved or deformed during insertion, manipulation, or retention.
5.2 Possible Causes
Potential causes include:
Excessive insertion force.
Contact with resistant tissue or bone.
Improper needle manipulation.
Movement by the patient while the needle is inserted.
Pressure or impact on the exposed needle handle.
Attempts to forcefully remove a stuck needle.
5.3 Signs and Symptoms
The needle may appear visibly curved, and its handle may no longer align with the original insertion direction. Manipulation or withdrawal may become difficult and painful.
5.4 Management Principles
If a needle bends, manipulation should stop immediately. The practitioner should explain the situation and ask the patient to remain still.
A slightly bent needle may sometimes be removed gently by a trained practitioner if it can be done safely. A severely bent needle, a needle associated with significant pain, or one that cannot be withdrawn without force requires appropriate clinical assessment.
The practitioner must not force the needle out or continue manipulating it in an attempt to straighten it inside the body.
5.5 Prevention
Use needles that meet applicable quality standards.
Inspect needles before use.
Apply controlled insertion and manipulation techniques.
Select a stable and comfortable patient position.
Protect exposed needle handles from accidental pressure or impact.
Address resistance promptly rather than forcing the needle.
Key learning point: A bent needle requires a controlled response. Forceful removal may increase the risk of tissue injury or needle breakage.
6. Broken Needle
6.1 Definition
A broken needle is an acupuncture needle that fractures while part of the needle remains in the patient’s body.
6.2 Possible Causes
Potential contributing factors include:
A defective, damaged, or corroded needle.
Excessive force during insertion or manipulation.
Sudden patient movement.
Pressure on the exposed needle handle.
Forceful attempts to remove a stuck or bent needle.
Equipment malfunction or inappropriate operation during electroacupuncture.
6.3 Signs and Symptoms
The needle may break above the skin, at the skin surface, or beneath the skin. A fragment may be visible or may remain completely embedded.
6.4 Immediate Response
A broken needle is a potentially serious procedural complication.
The practitioner should stop the procedure, keep the patient still, and avoid pressing, probing, or manipulating the affected area. If a fragment is visible, it should not be pushed farther into the tissue.
The practitioner should arrange prompt medical assessment. A deeply embedded fragment may require medical imaging and removal by an appropriately qualified healthcare professional.
Blind attempts to locate or extract a buried fragment can cause additional injury and should be avoided.
6.5 Prevention
Inspect each needle before use.
Use appropriate, undamaged needles from reliable sources.
Avoid excessive force during insertion and manipulation.
Ensure the patient understands the importance of remaining still.
Never forcefully extract a stuck or bent needle.
Follow the manufacturer’s instructions and professional standards for electroacupuncture equipment.
Key learning point: If a needle breaks, do not attempt blind removal. Prevent further movement of the fragment and arrange appropriate medical assessment.
7. Hematoma
7.1 Definition
A hematoma is a collection of blood within tissue, usually caused by damage to a small blood vessel. After acupuncture, it may appear as localized swelling, tenderness, or blue-purple discoloration.
A small bruise and a significant hematoma are not the same. The extent of the bleeding and the patient’s symptoms help determine whether further assessment is necessary.
7.2 Possible Causes
A hematoma may occur when a needle injures a blood vessel or surrounding tissue. The risk may be greater in some anatomical locations or in people who have bleeding disorders or take anticoagulant medication.
7.3 Signs and Symptoms
Possible signs include:
Localized swelling.
Tenderness or pain.
Blue, purple, or dark discoloration.
Bruising that develops after needle withdrawal.
Rapidly increasing swelling, severe pain, ongoing bleeding, or symptoms suggesting pressure on nearby structures require prompt medical assessment.
7.4 Management Principles
For a small bruise without concerning symptoms, observation may be sufficient. Gentle pressure with clean or sterile gauze may help control minor bleeding immediately after needle withdrawal.
A cold pack wrapped in a cloth may be used briefly for minor bruising if appropriate. Direct ice application and vigorous massage should be avoided.
Large or expanding hematomas, persistent bleeding, significant pain, or symptoms affecting movement or sensation require medical assessment. People taking anticoagulants or living with a bleeding disorder may need additional precautions.
7.5 Prevention
Understand the anatomy of the treatment area.
Use appropriate insertion depth and direction.
Inspect the needle before use.
Ask about bleeding disorders and medications that may affect clotting.
Apply appropriate pressure after needle withdrawal when needed.
Observe the puncture site for unexpected bleeding or swelling.
Key learning point: Bruising may occur after needling, but substantial or expanding swelling should not be dismissed as a routine reaction.
8. Injury to Internal Structures
Acupuncture involves inserting needles through the skin into underlying tissues. Because the body contains organs, blood vessels, nerves, and other sensitive structures, accurate anatomical knowledge is essential.
The risk of injury depends on the location, insertion depth and direction, patient anatomy, and clinical circumstances.
8.1 Traumatic Pneumothorax
A traumatic pneumothorax occurs when air enters the space between the lung and the chest wall, potentially causing part or all of the lung to collapse.
In acupuncture, this complication can occur if a needle penetrates the lung or nearby structures, particularly in vulnerable areas of the chest, upper back, or shoulder region.
Possible warning signs include:
Sudden or worsening chest pain.
Shortness of breath.
Chest tightness.
Rapid breathing or heartbeat.
Dizziness or collapse.
Symptoms may begin immediately or develop later. The absence of immediate symptoms does not completely exclude an injury.
A suspected pneumothorax requires urgent medical evaluation. Severe breathing difficulty, bluish discoloration of the lips or skin, fainting, or signs of circulatory collapse require emergency services. The practitioner should not assume that the problem will resolve on its own.
Prevention requires detailed anatomical knowledge, appropriate patient positioning, and strict adherence to the insertion depth and direction specified by professional training and clinical standards. Needling in high-risk areas should only be performed by practitioners with the necessary competence.
8.2 Injury to Abdominal or Other Internal Organs
Depending on the location and depth of insertion, an acupuncture needle may injure internal organs or nearby blood vessels. Potentially affected structures include the liver, spleen, kidneys, bladder, intestines, and other organs.
The risk can vary with body composition, organ position, underlying medical conditions, and the location of the needle.
Possible warning signs include:
New or increasing abdominal or back pain.
Significant tenderness.
Abdominal swelling or rigidity.
Blood in the urine.
Dizziness, weakness, or fainting.
Signs of internal bleeding or shock.
Internal bleeding may not always be visible externally. Severe or worsening pain, fainting, marked weakness, or other concerning symptoms after needling require urgent medical evaluation.
A suspected internal-organ injury must not be managed through home observation alone. The patient may require emergency assessment, diagnostic imaging, monitoring, or other medical treatment.
Prevention depends on accurate anatomical knowledge, careful selection of insertion sites, and strict adherence to appropriate depth and direction. Additional caution is required when anatomy may be altered by disease or other medical conditions.
8.3 Injury to the Brain, Spinal Cord, or Nearby Structures
The brainstem and spinal cord are highly sensitive structures. Needling in certain areas of the head, neck, and spine therefore requires particular anatomical knowledge and technical competence.
Improper needle direction or excessive depth may injure neural tissue or nearby blood vessels.
Possible warning signs include:
Sudden severe or unusual pain.
An electric-shock-like sensation spreading into an arm or leg.
New numbness or weakness.
Difficulty walking or coordinating movement.
Severe headache, dizziness, or changes in consciousness.
New neurological symptoms after acupuncture require prompt medical assessment. Sudden weakness, difficulty walking, loss of consciousness, or other severe symptoms warrant emergency care.
Prevention requires appropriate training in regional anatomy, conservative technique, careful observation of the patient’s responses, and strict avoidance of forceful manipulation in high-risk areas.
8.4 Peripheral Nerve Injury
Peripheral nerves carry sensory information and motor signals between the central nervous system and the rest of the body.
A needle that contacts or injures a nerve may produce sharp, shooting, burning, or electric-shock-like sensations. Persistent pain, numbness, tingling, weakness, or changes in movement may indicate a more significant problem.
A brief unusual sensation should not automatically be interpreted as deqi. If an electric-shock-like or radiating sensation occurs, the practitioner should stop the provoking manipulation and reassess the situation rather than repeatedly stimulating the same area.
Persistent or worsening neurological symptoms require medical evaluation.
9. General Precautions for Acupuncture
Safe acupuncture practice requires patient assessment, anatomical knowledge, suitable equipment, careful technique, and ongoing observation.
9.1 Assess the Patient Before Treatment
Before treatment, the practitioner should review relevant medical history, current symptoms, previous reactions to acupuncture, medications, and factors that may increase risk.
Particular attention is needed when a patient is unwell, unusually fatigued, dehydrated, anxious, or has a history of fainting. Treatment may need to be postponed or modified according to the patient’s condition and the applicable professional standards.
9.2 Consider Bleeding Risk
People with bleeding disorders, low platelet counts, or medications that affect blood clotting may have an increased risk of bleeding or hematoma.
These conditions do not all create the same level of risk. A qualified practitioner should assess the patient’s circumstances and follow relevant professional guidance rather than applying one rule to every patient.
9.3 Use Extra Caution During Pregnancy
Pregnancy requires specific clinical assessment and knowledge of applicable acupuncture precautions. Decisions should consider the stage of pregnancy, the treatment purpose, the patient’s medical history, and the practitioner’s qualifications.
Some traditional acupuncture teachings identify particular acupoints and abdominal regions as requiring special caution during pregnancy. However, traditional lists of contraindicated points should not be treated as a complete substitute for current clinical guidance.
Pregnant patients should receive care from appropriately trained practitioners who understand pregnancy-related precautions and referral requirements.
9.4 Consider Infants and Children
Infants and children require age-appropriate assessment and specialized training. Their anatomy, ability to remain still, and response to procedures differ from those of adults.
Practitioners must follow applicable pediatric standards and avoid procedures that are unsuitable for the child’s age, condition, or ability to cooperate.
9.5 Avoid Infected or Damaged Skin
Needling through infected, ulcerated, or otherwise unsuitable skin can increase the risk of complications. Skin lesions or masses should be assessed appropriately before selecting a treatment site.
The practitioner should follow infection-prevention standards, including hand hygiene, appropriate skin preparation when indicated, and the use of sterile, single-use acupuncture needles.
9.6 Use Caution Near the Chest, Neck, Spine, and Eyes
Some anatomical regions contain structures that can be seriously injured by incorrect needling.
The chest and upper back require particular awareness of the lungs and pleural cavity. The neck and spinal regions contain major blood vessels, nerves, and the spinal cord. The area around the eyes contains delicate tissues and important structures.
Needling in these regions should only be performed by appropriately trained practitioners using techniques suitable for the specific anatomical location. Insertion depth, direction, patient position, and manipulation must follow professional training and applicable standards.
9.7 Monitor the Patient Throughout Treatment
Observation should continue during insertion, manipulation, retention, and withdrawal.
Practitioners should respond promptly to unexpected pain, dizziness, nausea, sweating, breathing difficulty, unusual bleeding, or neurological symptoms. A treatment plan should never take priority over a patient’s immediate safety.
10. When to Seek Emergency Medical Care
The following signs after acupuncture require urgent attention:
Severe or worsening difficulty breathing.
Sudden chest pain.
Loss of consciousness or failure to recover promptly.
Severe or increasing abdominal pain.
Significant or uncontrolled bleeding.
Rapidly expanding swelling.
New weakness, numbness, or difficulty walking.
Sudden severe headache or altered consciousness.
In Canada, call 911 for a life-threatening emergency. Do not delay emergency care while attempting additional acupuncture techniques or other traditional interventions.
Conclusion
Needle retention and withdrawal are fundamental parts of acupuncture technique, but they must be understood within the broader context of patient safety.
Needle fainting, needle entrapment, bent or broken needles, hematomas, and injuries to internal structures require different responses. The common principles are to recognize unexpected changes early, stop unsafe manipulation, avoid forceful removal, and obtain appropriate medical assistance when needed.
As I continue studying acupuncture techniques, I am learning that competent practice depends not only on knowing how to insert and manipulate a needle, but also on understanding anatomy, observing the patient carefully, and recognizing the limits of acupuncture care.
Educational disclaimer: This article summarizes general learning points about acupuncture procedures and safety. It is not a clinical protocol or a substitute for supervised training, professional standards, or medical assessment. Acupuncture should be performed only by appropriately qualified practitioners.